(originally published on February 16, 2008)
1. The University of Michigan’s consumer sentiment index tumbled to 69.6 in its preliminary February reading from 78.4 last month, marking its lowest point since February 1992 when the economy was emerging from a recession. The component of the index that gauges consumers’ expectations — a possible sign of their willingness to spend — dropped to to 59.4 from 68.1.
Sharp plunge in consumer sentiment in last few months
As noted in the chart above, the dip in consumer sentiment is startling. Consumer confidence is now even below the lows seen in 2001-2002 recession and close to its worst levels since the early 1990s, when unemployment rate was up over 7%.
2. The New York Fed's 'Empire State' index, a widely tracked gauge of manufacturing growth fell for the fourth consecutive month in February to its weakest level since April 2003. The general business conditions index slipped alarmingly to minus 11.72 in February from plus 9.03 the previous month, the first negative reading in almost two years. Readings below zero signal contraction.
Empire State index: manufacturing takes a hit as well
These reports are not isolated. Best Buy, the largest U.S. consumer electronics chain, cut its full-year revenue and earnings forecast this week driven by what it termed 'soft domestic customer traffic in January... and weak near-term outlook'. The ABC News/Washington Post Consumer Comfort Index fell to its lowest reading since November 1993. Fewer than half of Americans surveyed rated their own finances positively, again a first since 1993. The Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI), a New-York based independent forecasting group, noted that its Weekly Leading Index skidded down to an annualized growth rate of minus 9.1 percent for the week ended February 8, its lowest reading since November 2001.
The evidence favoring a recession is now mounting. Economic growth screeched to a 0.6 percent stall in the fourth quarter. A quarterly survey issued by the Philadelphia Federal Reserve suggested a 47 percent probability of contraction in GDP this quarter and a 43 percent chance in the second quarter, levels not seen since the recession in 2001. Economists surveyed by Bloomberg and WSJ earlier this month forecast even odds of a recession. A contracting labor market (payrolls declined for the first time in four years in January) and sharp weakness across the services sector that accounts for 85-90% of the economy (ISM non-manufacturing index fell off a cliff to its lowest since 9/11 ) amplify the chances of the economy turning over into a recession this quarter. The housing slump has only accelerated further over the past few months. Builders broke ground at an annual rate of just over a million homes in December, the fewest since 1991. The National Association of Realtors estimates sales of existing homes fell more than forecast in December, while prices of single-family homes posted the biggest annual drop probably since the Great Depression.
Corporate earnings are also taking a hit. Bloomberg data suggest that the S&P 500 companies that have reported 4Q 2007 earnings thus far posted an average 15 percent decline in earnings. The outlook for the first two quarters of the year is not much better either, with analysts expecting a 1.4 percent and 0.7 percent decline in earnings. The only bastion of hope is the rise in exports, driven by sustained weakness in the dollar and more resilient economic growth abroad. US trade deficit shrunk 6.2 percent to $711.6 billion in 2007 from its record set in 2006, the largest annual percentage drop since 1991 and its first decline in six years. But as global growth falters, partly weighed down by the slowdown in the US, it remains to be seen if there would be enough takers for US exports going forward.
The gloom has spread steadily over the past few months, with the odds of a recession rising as economic data has turned nastier. Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan now believes that the economy is "clearly on the edge", putting the odds of an economic contraction at "50 percent or better", up from his guesstimate of a one-in-three chance just a few months ago. His successor, Ben Bernanke, asserted in a Congressional testimony that policy makers were prepared to lower rates further as the economy hurtles in its downward spiral, vowing to provide “adequate insurance against downside risks”. He essentially said, as nearly as a Fed Chairman can, that we were indeed headed towards a recession. The telling statement: “More-expensive and less-available credit seems likely to continue to be a source of restraint on economic growth”. This sense of caution, despite the "substantive additional action" of a 125 bps rate cutting blitzkrieg in January - the fastest pace of monetary policy easing in over two decades - will only serve to heighten anxiety in the minds of market participants.
History has taught us that economies do not normally slip gradually into recession; they plunge spectacularly as they turn over. This usually creates glaring discontinuities in the incoming economic data, of the sort clearly on display in the survey reports of the past few weeks. A degree of panic seems to have set in that could possibly tip the scales in a stalling economy, pushing it into a free fall.
No comments:
Post a Comment